In a previous post, I’d alluded to a couple of strokes of luck that I had here and there that opened up some opportunities which eventually led to my current location and position. Some commenters felt that I hadn’t acknowledged that I may have been “luckier” than others and that I was in some way looking down on those that hadn’t been so fortunate.
Given that the theme of January’s Scientiae is “As one door closes, another one opens. Likewise, as one door opens, another one closes” and that I had never gotten off my ass in time to submit anything for previous Scientiae carnivals, I figured that this was as good a time as any to provide one example of how having a door opened for me helped my career … and how I almost fucked it up.
After taking a very circuitous route through two undergrad degrees, a postgrad honors degree and a multitude of horrible jobs, I knew that a career in academia was what I wanted.
There were only two PhD programs I was interested in pursuing: one in my home town (well, actually it’s a big city) at the highly respected school where I had completed my honors degree and the other at another school in a bigger city elsewhere in the land far, far away.
I interviewed first at the latter school and while they were prepared to sign me up right away, the PI I was most interested in working with was about to disappear on a lengthy sabbatical.
None of the faculty at the school in my home town were working in my field of interest but my honors advisor informed me that a young, new assistant professor, Dr C, had just arrived who not only shared my research interests, but was also keen to meet me as he’d heard good things about me through the school’s grapevine.
At the time, I was working in a commercial pathology lab; I had worked full time at this lab for most of my honors degree which made it an incredibly stressful time but I had to pay my rent and buy food somehow and it was a good way to get more lab-based sciencey experience.
And so it was that I contacted Dr C via email and set up a meeting for late one afternoon after my shift at the pathology lab was finished.
I should have had this opportunity in the bag, right? Perhaps, except that I didn’t think things through well enough.
I commuted everywhere on my bicycle and didn’t think twice about riding from work to the school and knocking on Dr C’s door wearing lycra from head to toe – after all, I had attended all of my honor’s classes wearing the same gear.
Needless to say, his first impression of me was not favorable.
To make matters worse, when asked WHY I wanted to pursue a PhD, my answer was something along the lines of “well, I hate the job I’m doing right now so I want to do something else”.
Fucking idiot.
It wasn’t until Dr C stood up and told me to go away and think about whether grad school was what I REALLY wanted to do that it finally dawned on me that I had well and truly fucked up. WTF was I thinking??
The reality was that I had been awake since 3am that morning in order to do the 45 min cycle commute before showering, eating and starting work at 5am and had been working extra long shifts that week to cover for a coworker who was on vacation. I should have scheduled the interview for another time when I knew my mind would be functioning better than a bowl of jello.
When I got home, I emailed Dr C, apologized profusely, explained the situation, reiterated that grad school WAS what I wanted and why I wanted to work with him and he very graciously granted me a second chance interview.
After all of that, I did join Dr C’s new lab, continued to work at the pathology lab for my first year as well as working as a TA until I got a scholarship, then continued to teach while I worked my ass off on my thesis and published everything I got my hands on in very good journals. Dr C and I continue to have a great relationship and we have several ongoing projects being undertaken by the grad students we co-advise. The opportunity he gave me and the freedom he afforded me during my thesis work set me up for a very successful postdoc and subsequent job search.
So while I was very fortunate that Dr C had joined the faculty just at the right time and offered to open a door for me, I had slammed it in my own stupid face. Despite my own fuckwittery, I’m in this position today because I made the most of an opportunity, not because someone handed it to me on a silver platter.
scientiae-carnival
bye bye week
18 hours ago

Has your experience with Dr. C (giving you the second chance) affected how you formulate an opinion of a potential student (or postdoc or coworker or mate) based on first impressions?
ReplyDeleteI find that I'm very quick to judge, so I really have to work to overcome first impressions (my poor students!!!).
I'm also quick to judge based on first impressions which have, more often than not, proved to be misleading. It's something I've been trying to work on for a long time but I'm not sure that my experience with Dr C was the catalyst for that. I think the excellent recommendations he'd received about me from a couple of the faculty went a long way towards him giving me a second chance.
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing.
ReplyDeleteBut don't you think that both he’d heard good things about me through the school’s grapevine
and
the excellent recommendations he'd received about me
could be tantamount to a silver platter? Maybe at least a tray with shiny paint?
I recently had something like this happen for me, where someone pulled a string and voila! Something that had been very difficult suddenly became doable.
But I credit THAT PERSON, the string-puller, with helping me. At least as much as I credit myself for working hard and deserving the benefits of that opportunity.
I'm sure you know this, though. You strike me as the sort of person who knows enough to thank everyone who recommended you and keep your network happily fed.
But don't discount the benefits of a happy network as an ADVANTAGE that not everyone has.
And I have to say as an aside to both you an U.R., I think first impressions are important, but appearances are not.
The way you told the story, I agree that scheduling the meeting for a different time would have been better.
But what's wrong with lycra (not that I have worn it in years)?
Maybe it depends on where you live. Where I currently live and work, appearances are not so important. The bar is just lower, I guess. If you were wearing a clownsuit, okay that would be weird. But for biking, there's a perfectly practical reason. And from the sound of it, you didn't have an alternative means of transportation? I guess you could have scheduled time to change clothes after you arrived?
Anyway it seems to have all worked out just fine for you. Really great that it worked to just call and apologize. That's a skill, right there, being able to take your proverbial lycra-covered foot out of your mouth.
But don't you think that both "he’d heard good things about me through the school’s grapevine" and "the excellent recommendations he'd received about me" could be tantamount to a silver platter? Maybe at least a tray with shiny paint?
ReplyDeleteNo - I think it all part of networking. There were only 3 profs in the school working in the same field and out of the 4 honors students that year, I was the only one that graduated with first class honors so it was more of a personal recommendation by my honors advisor than string pulling.
And you're totally correct in that I was extremely grateful that my honors advisor had made the recommendation. Not so much for keeping my network happy, but more just to thank him personally - the honors year was an incredibly stressful experience, particularly as I was also holding down a full time job, and my advisor helped me keep it together both professionally and personally during that time.
But what's wrong with lycra ...
Dr C was wearing a shirt and tie and I walked in wearing a body-hugging cycling jersey, crotch-padded knicks and socks with no shoes as I couldn't walking in my cleated cycling shoes. The faculty were all very sporty people but this was definitely inappropriate attire for meeting with a professor for the first time to talk about joining his lab. Appearances aren't that important, but making an effort to make a good first impression is ... although I definitely made a strong first impression on him!
Crap - I knew I forgot something ...
ReplyDeleteBut don't discount the benefits of a happy network as an ADVANTAGE that not everyone has.
I agree, but this doesn't have to be a formal thing and is something than one can cultivate for themselves although it does take some time. A good working relationship or making a good impression on one person can lead to meeting another person and so on. This can be as simple as asking a question at a seminar/meeting, approaching a postdoc or PI about using/stealing something from their lab or asking another PI's opinion on something. Even chatting to people during poster sessions at meetings can lead to collaborations, potential job opportunities etc - often I've been chatting to a student or postdoc and their PI has walked up and joined the conversation. You'd be surprised how small a community science actually is and that people often know who you are before you meet them.